Saturday Forum
Print Friendly and PDF

01/29/10 - A TX Reader Says Mexican Consulate Needs Public Relations Refresher Course

A California Reader Says Charge Immigrants For English Instruction!; etc.

From: Pat Maple (e-mail him)

Re: Joe Guzzardi's Column: Lodi School Budget Deficit Tied Directly To Immigration

I spent 14 years on school boards and saw little progress in the language assimilation of many, if not most, of the Hispanic children. The English as a Second Language and English language earner system that is presently used in our school system does not work.

Since the students aren't learning, the answer is to make them pay at least a modest fee to take the burden off the taxpayer. Non-English speaking parents should also be mandated to English classes

The consequences of Hispanic K-12 students not mastering English is dire. In a conversation with a Board member from the Fresno District, he mentioned that the school is being taken over by the state because of so-called fiscal irresponsibility.

In reality, my source identified unfunded mandates like ELL, ESL and other Hispanic related programs such as gang mediation that led to its near bankruptcy. Fresno spent well over $150 million per year educating the Hispanic population. And each year the test scores were worse and the budget crisis deeper.

California cannot educate students from hundreds of cultures. It's nuts to pretend it can. Which is easier: catering to immigrants' individual needs or insisting the immigrants assimilate?

Talking about getting immigrants out of those ever present shadows is one thing but doing something about it is another. The best way for them to come out is to learn English.

Maple, a roofer, lives in the San Joaquin Valley.

[PermaLink] [Top] [Letters Home]

But Another California Reader Calls Joe Guzzardi A "Disgrace"; Joe Replies

From:  Eddie Robinson (e-mail him)

For years Guzzardi earned his living teaching English as a Second Language to immigrants. Now that he is retired and collecting his fat state teacher retirement check, he wants to end ESL programs.

I note also that Guzzardi doesn't mention Asian students but only the Hispanics that he holds in such low regard.

Guzzardi is a racist, a hypocrite and a disgrace.

Joe Guzzardi replies: One of the extraordinary things about being a columnist is the mail that comes across my desk. Often times I have to pause to figure out which column my correspondent is referring to, so little does his letter have in common with what I wrote.

Robinson's letter is one such case. I never wrote that ESL classes should be discontinued. Nor did I propose (although I endorse the concept) that ESL students should pay for their second language instruction—as did letter writer Pat Maple above.

Robinson is wrong in his claim that I omitted Asians. I mentioned Asians but excluded them from my cost analysis because, as I noted, they are for the most part in the U.S. legally; Southeast Asian war refugees and their American-born children.

What my column did is break down the costs of educating Hispanic students, all of whom are in California's schools because of immigration. I left it to the reader to decide if the benefits outweigh the costs.

As for my "fat" check, LOL. I was a non-contracted, non-union, part-time adult school employee, paid by the hour.

[PermaLink] [Top] [Letters Home]

An Idaho PhD. Says When It Comes To Haiti, Americans Are Plenty Smart—The Problem Is Their Government

From: Robert Murray (e-mail him)

Re: Patrick Cleburne's Blog: Wiser Than America: Neighboring Dominican Republic Refuse Haitian Influx

I resent the notion Cleburne presented that America is less wise than the Dominican Republic because we are willing to accept Haitian refugees while it is not.

What Cleburne means is that the United States government, specifically President Barack Obama, is less wise than its citizens.

Most Americans are for less legal and no illegal immigration. (VDARE.COM note: Better yet, how about an immigration moratorium?)

The question is why does our leadership want more diversity when we already have so much of it?

Murray attended forestry school at the University of Montana (BSF and MSF) and earned a Ph.D. in Plant Ecology at Washington State University. His previous letters about his former Senator Craig and Mike Crapo, hiring foreign-born teachers, Cardinal Roger Mahony and the U.S. immigration crisis are here, here, here and here.

[PermaLink] [Top] [Letters Home]

A Los Angeles Reader, Former Democrat, Says Ted Kennedy From The Grave Cannot Help Any Democrat

From: Arnold Portocarreo (e-mail him)

Re: Joe Guzzardi's Column: Accentuate The Positive, Eliminate The Negative! Harry Reid, Amnesty Won't Make It

Guzzardi wrote that during his campaign Harry Reid may use pre-recorded endorsements made by the late Senator Ted Kennedy

For Reid's sake, not that I wish him well in any way, I hope Kennedy didn't tape his ad in Spanish. Never in recorded history has a Romance language been so tortured.

I heard Kennedy address a large gathering of illegal aliens at the Los Angeles Community College promising them, falsely as it turned out, that "we are going to win" (Listen here.)

I immediately changed my voter registration to Independent rather than to remain in the same political party with Kennedy who represented everything that is wrong with our political system: elitism, irresponsibility, and a cynical contempt for the nation that gave him and his family so much.

While I don't rejoice in the death of a fellow human being and recognize the loss to his family, Kennedy's passing is a good thing for America in our battle for patriotic immigration reform.

Portocarreo's previous letter about Internet matchmaking is here.

[PermaLink] [Top] [Letters Home]

Print Friendly and PDF