The debate's focus centers on who is to blame for the sad death of this young girl.
Most of the attention correctly falls on Jimenez's employer, Merced Farm Labor, a contractor with a history of disregarding worker safety.
But the list of accomplices is long.
Accordingly, with Mexico's blessing and encouragement, the most desperate of its populace seeks haven in the United States.
Unbelievably and without a critical word from the U.S., two years ago Mexico issued a comic book titled Guide for the Mexican Migrant, with helpful hints about how to cross into America and stay out of trouble once you arrive.
Is, I wonder, Jimenez one of Fox's heroes?
Since his first days in the White House, Bush has repeatedly uttered such nonsense as "family values don't stop at the Rio Grande," "America is a nation of immigrants," and "immigrants do jobs Americans won't do."
Each statement grossly distorts the truth and is interpreted in Mexico as an open invitation to come north.
As recently as a week ago, Bush pulled the National Guard from the border making it easier yet to cross into the southwestern United States.
As an enormously popular Hollywood movie star/legal immigrant, Schwarzenegger could have shifted the state's bitter argument about illegal immigration to a higher plane by reinforcing the concept of obeying immigration law.
Instead, Schwarzenegger fell in line with Bush by endorsing amnesty. Any statement that encourages amnesty welcomes illegal immigrants—come on over, you may get lucky!
For the last three years, you've seen them waving their placards at illegal alien May Day protest marches: "No human is illegal!"—as if enforcing immigration law were a statement about the human condition.
The phrase "undocumented worker" never existed until the media coined it. And America's debate is not—as the media would have you believe—about "immigrants and immigration" but about illegal immigration.
As the media knows but ignores, an immigrant is someone who enters the U.S through a port of entry with a valid visa—not someone who climbs over a wire fence in the dark of night.
And in the last ten years, the U.S. has become even more gracious to illegal immigrants—offering home mortgages, accepting transparently fake identification as valid work documents and even, in some states issuing driver's licenses.
At the same time, obvious flaws in our immigration system remain unchecked. Jimenez's case brings to mind the foolish birthright citizenship clause that would have allowed her child to become an American citizen.
Birthright citizenship was ended years ago in most Western countries.
California has revoked Merced Farm Labor's license. [State to Revoke License Of Merced Farm Labor, By Susan Ferriss, Sacramento Bee, June 5, 2008]
That's not enough. I'd like to see the principals sentenced to long jail terms and meaningful monetary fines.
For those indirectly responsible, listed above, may they come to their senses before more lives are needlessly lost.