Perdue Flops, Durbin Blocks—The Latest On Congress’ Indian Green Card Giveaway
Print Friendly and PDF

The Fairness for High-Skilled Immigrants Act continues to be blocked, but it just won’t die. Last week, the cheap labor giveaway was blocked by Georgia Sen. David Perdue, generally an immigration patriot, but weak on cheap labor. (NumbersUSA rating B—but F- on “Reduce Unnecessary Worker Visas”.) On Thursday, it was blocked by Democratic Illinois Sen. Dick Durbin, further delaying its passage [Sen. Durbin Delays Green-Card Giveaway to India: He Wants a Bigger Giveaway, by Neil Munro, Breitbart, September 26, 2019].

Durbin didn’t block the bill because it would hurt American workers—he blocked it because it didn’t increase immigration enough. He would like the bill to give green cards to foreigners who graduate from American universities and make sure it doesn’t cut down on the number of immigrants from countries besides China and India.

For readers, who may not be familiar with the Fairness for High-Skilled Immigrants Act, here’s a quick summary:

The bill would eliminate country caps on visas, which prevents one or two nationalities from dominating our immigration system. The elimination would most benefit Indians and Chinese, with Indians estimated to receive at least 75 percent of all employment-based visas under the act. Besides Indians and Chinese immigrants, Big Tech is the biggest champion of the bill—the industry wants its cheap foreign labor. The House overwhelmingly passed the bill in July; only 57 Republicans and a handful of Democrats voted against it.

This is another obstacle for Utah Sen. Mike Lee, the bill’s chief proponent, to overcome. While the bill sailed through the House, it keeps hitting snags in the Senate. Sen. Rand Paul blocked a unanimous consent vote in June, and Perdue and Durbin did the same this month.

However, Perdue no longer objects to a unanimous consent vote and claims he always supported the bill.

This is a depressing message to immigration patriots and puts him in the same class as Tom Cotton, another supposed immigration patriot who supports the bill. This increases the bill’s chances at passage.

Lee just now has to convince Durbin and other Democrats to vote for the bill. That may motivate him to offer immigration increases that would dissuade Perdue, Cotton and Josh Hawley from supporting it.

The latest news is not good, but the bill is not a sure deal yet. VDARE will continue to monitor this story closely.



Print Friendly and PDF