Tucker Carlson: Immigration Is Not Always Beneficial for America
Print Friendly and PDF

Tucker Carlson’s opening monologue on Wednesday discussed the open borders now creating chaos for law enforcement and future pain for taxpayers. This was the crisis that millions of citizens voted to fix in 2016, but President Trump has not gone after the central problem, just nipped around the edges. Certainly President Hillary would be far worse, but that’s not much consolation. As Tucker pointed out, Democrats appear to prefer foreigners to American citizens.

And the foreigners prefer their home country to the United States — why else would Hondurans make a big show of carrying their flag on the way to the US (as shown below)? That’s the behavior of illegal alien invaders, not friendly immigrants.

It would be nice if Trump’s suggestion to tax remittances, mentioned by Tucker, could go forward because there is some serious money involved. The Washington Examiner recently reported that $17 billion in remittances was sent to Guatemala, Honduras and El Salvador last year alone.

As it happens, I wrote an opinion piece in 2002 suggesting that remittances be taxed which I believe was the first instance of such a strategy being proposed. It’s good to see it filter around.

TUCKER CARLSON: Good evening and welcome to “Tucker Carlson Tonight.” There is a loud debate going on in Washington right now, one that we participate in about border security whether to build a wall, how much funding ICE should get, whether our detention centers are big enough to hold everyone they need to hold. People argue about these questions every day. You watch it on TV.

And so it seems like, the parties are divided on the matter. But on a deeper level there really is no debate, there is instead consensus. Virtually everyone in the political system knows as an article of faith that mass immigration is good for our economy. Immigrants make us richer. The Chamber of Commerce tells us that often. Libertarian think tanks produce studies claiming to prove it’s true.

In the Democratic Party, it is a bedrock principle. America would collapse without a steady torrent of new arrivals from the developing world. That is what they tell us. Immigration does not just improve the economy, we wouldn’t have an economy without it.

FORMER FIRST LADY HILLARY CLINTON: I want us to be a country where hardworking immigrants who pay taxes, and by the way, one half undocumented workers pay Federal income taxes.

FORMER VICE PRESIDENT JOE BIDEN: These people are just waiting — waiting for a chance to be able to contribute fully and by that standard, 11 million undocumented aliens are already Americans in my view.

FORMER PRESIDENT BILL CLINTON: We cannot continue to grow this economy unless we grow more diverse and take more immigrants.

FORMER PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: Our history and the facts show that immigrants are a net plus for the economy and our society.

CARLSON: Half of the illegals pay their taxes, says Hillary Clinton. You should be impressed and grateful. Well, this is not a new talking point as you could tell from the aging video we showed you, but like everything in this country, it has accelerated dramatically the past couple of years.

The left’s new position is that immigrants are not just good for America, they are better for America than you are. They don’t complain, they don’t file H.R. complaints. They don’t get expensive long-term diseases like diabetes or opioid addiction, they just do what they’re told. They are the noble workers our leaders have always wanted.

Just two days ago, Senator Kristen Gillibrand of New York, who by the way is running for President, explained that every single immigrant in America is good, no matter how they got here or why, just by virtue of the fact that they are immigrants. Ever heard anybody say that about American citizens? No, don’t hold your breath. But Gillibrand clearly meant it about immigrants. Watch.

SENATOR KIRSTEN GILLIBRAND: There is no such thing as an illegal human. You have immigrant populations across the state, refugee populations that make your economy stronger, that make the city and state stronger, that make this country stronger.

CARLSON: Falsest person in Washington, but she is saying something that everyone else believes. Immigrants makes our economy stronger. Okay, that’s the claim. It is it true? Well in some cases, it is true. Plenty of immigrants have done a great job in this country. They are highly patriotic. They are successful in business. They are great neighbors and friends. Everybody knows people like that and everybody is glad they are here.

But not every immigrant is like every other immigrant. Now, don’t tell Kirsten Gillibrand, but they are not all the same. Our current immigration system treats them like they are. It treats people like widgets. Our government does virtually nothing to separate the good from the bad. A system like that is not designed to help America, it is designed for the benefit of foreigners, and by that measure, it has been wildly successful.

A new study shows that just last year, immigrants living in the United States send at least $120 billion in remittances to the countries they came from. Even in the age of expanding cost, $120 billion is a lot of money. It is more for example then we spent on the first Gulf War. It is more than the entire Russian military spends every two years. That’s enough money to buy Costco, not the stuff on the shelves, but the entire company and still have $15 billion left over. It is a lot of money and all of it could be going to Americans, many of whom badly need it.

But instead, Mexico received $33 billion in remittances just last year. That country’s own President admits the Mexican economy would go under without those remittance payments. In Guatemala, remittances from the United States amounted to a full 11% of their entire GDP. In El Salvador and Honduras, that is 18% and 20% respectively.

In the past decades, those three countries have received a total of $120 billion in remittances from the United States. And by the way, it’s not just Latin America that is benefiting from this. China which hardly needs it, gets $15 billion a year in remittances. India $10.5 billion; Vietnam, $7 billion; Nigeria, $5.5 billion; Russia, $300 million. We could go on and on.

Now, none of this is an attack on immigrants. In most cases, they are just helping their families back home and good for them, it’s not their fault. It is our fault. Much of this money has never been taxed at any level. More than 10 million illegal aliens are believed to be working in this country under the table. And that is part of the reason that between 2012 and 2016, an estimated 39 million Social Security numbers were stolen from Americans for fraudulent use. A fact that’s rarely reported.

But legal or not, immigrants send their earnings abroad and they pay nothing when they do it because remittances are untaxed. It is a pretty good deal for Mexico and Guatemala. When was the last time, you made a financial transaction that wasn’t taxed? Can you even remember?

At one point, the Trump administration proposed a remittance tax. Lobbyists from Mexico didn’t like the idea. The idea went nowhere. We can’t fix that on this show, what we can do is be honest about what is happening.

Immigration is good for the economy, sure, it can be good. Immigration is always good for our economy? More immigration is always better for our economy? No. That is a lie. There is nothing to support that claim. There is a lot of evidence to disprove it. Anyone who tells you that and that’s pretty much everyone you see on television either doesn’t understand the subject or is lying to you purposely and may be both, just so you know.

Print Friendly and PDF