President Bush's proposal to legalize the country's 10 or so million illegal aliens rests on a fallacy: that immigration enforcement has failed to stem the tide of illegal aliens. Therefore, the argument goes, amnesty is the only solution to the illegal-alien crisis.Mac Donald's simple observation — obvious to those who have long been toiling for immigration-sanity, but not widely recognized by the inattentive general public — is clearly a component of the attrition-through-enforcement strategy that is currently proving itself in real life.
But immigration enforcement has not failed – it has never been tried. Amnesty, however, has been tried, and it was a clear failure that should not be repeated again. [emphasis added]
Now, in the aftermath of the giant raid on Howard Industries, the Jackson, MS Clarion-Ledger has published a sober editorial (Immigration: Raid of this size raises questions, August 28, 2008) whose penultimate paragraph should be music to all VDARE readers' ears:
A raid of this size points to the complex issues involved in immigration reform efforts. The most effective reforms would be to enforce existing laws. [emphasis added]We could lay the illegal-immigration fight to rest and start on legal immigration if the Clarion-Ledger editors' insight would — please! — just go viral among their mainstream-media colleagues. (I'm an atheist, but everyone who's not should pray for this.) Meanwhile, VDARE's Mississippi readers can submit letters-to-the-editor lauding the Clarion-Ledger crew for recognizing reality.