Mexico Considers Closing Border To Americans To Prevent Coronavirus—Are They Racist Or Something?
Print Friendly and PDF

The Daily Mail reports that Mexico is thinking of closing its Frontera Norte—what Americans think of as the Mexican Border—at least to prevent entry by Americans, although I don't know if they'll try to stop Mexicans leaving.

My question is: are they racist or something? Everyone knows that only "nativists" try to prevent disease entering their country by closing borders.

In 2009, we had cases of the swine flu coming north from Mexico, and it raised civil rights issues.

From my 2009 blog post Civil Rights Law Doesn't Care If You Die:"Don't Even Think Of Noticing That A New Guest Is Arriving From Mexico...

From Walter Olson at

It can get tricky when 1) having swine flu may itself count as a protected disability under laws like California’s; 2) innkeepers are required to report communicable disease to authorities; 3) they must nonetheless avoid infringing customers’ privacy; and 4) they can face liability for not taking steps to protect fellow guests and their own workers. And don’t even think of noticing that a new guest is arriving from Mexico…

The relevant quote is from the hotel lawyers blog:

Q:Given all the publicity about the Swine Flu deaths in Mexico, should an innkeeper refuse guests Mexico?

A:The mere fact that there are many cases of Swine Flu in Mexico doesn't mean that everyone traveling from Mexico has the disease. Therefore, no blanket exclusion should be applied. Among other things, it could be argued that such a policy constitutes discrimination based on national origin in violation of both federal and state law.

Another case of Civil Rights Law Doesn't Care If You Die

Of course, Mexico has always had a more restrictive immigration policy than the US, they just say it's racist when the US does it.

Print Friendly and PDF