How does coronavirus affect the crime rate? The LA Times just ran an article about crime in Central America and Mexico.
(As of April 8, the coronavirus counts in these countries were: Mexico : 3131 cases, 157 deaths, Guatemala: 97 cases, 3 deaths, El Salvador: 108 cases, 6 deaths, Honduras: 319 cases, 22 deaths.)
From the LA Times:
El Salvador recently celebrated a historic feat: For two days in a row last month [March], the country recorded not a single homicide.
Driving the decline was not a gang truce or a new police strategy but a weeks-long national quarantine to slow the spread of the coronavirus.
The street gangs that have long terrorized El Salvador have now turned their attention from extortion and killing to a more pressing matter: enforcing social distancing restrictions, often with threats and baseball bats.
The gangs assumed their role as public health thugs after President Nayib Bukele ordered a 30-day lockdown that started March 22.
In many parts of the country, the gangs are more effective than government authorities, with tactics that include circulating recordings on messaging applications threatening people who break the rules.
“We don’t want to see anyone in the street,” says one recording. “If you go out, it better be only to the store, and you better be wearing a mask.” The gangs have also produced videos showing masked members hitting people for not adhering to the quarantine.
In El Salvador, gangs are enforcing the coronavirus lockdown with baseball bats , by Kate Linthicum, Molly O'Toole, and Alexander Renderos, Los Angeles Times, April 7, 2020
Not only that, but murder rates in El Salvador have been going down since 2015. The question is, who gets the credit for the pre-coronavirus decline?
In recent years, the government has taken what it calls an “iron fist” approach to criminal groups, sending soldiers armed with automatic weapons and dressed in black balaclavas into gang-controlled areas.
The country’s leaders say their strategy is working, pointing to a decline from peak homicide rates in 2015. Human rights organizations, though, blamed gangs for an uptick in forced disappearances, suggesting they were simply changing their tactics. Many believe the gangs have formed pacts with the government to keep bodies out of the streets.
“The gangs have retained their territorial control, and in many areas surpass the power of the state,” said Celia Medrano, the director of programs at human rights group Cristosal.
The fact that gangs appear to be enforcing the quarantine “just confirms that they are in control,” she said.
The gangs are certainly powerful in El Salvador.
The [Salvadoran] government has said that, in this nation of just over 6 million, nearly half a million people are connected to the gangs, which make money by extorting money from small businesses as well as smuggling and selling drugs.
The article describes the situation in the capital city.
In San Salvador, the nation’s capital, the streets are eerily empty.
On the day the national lockdown began, gang members in one Mara Salvatrucha-controlled neighborhood warned residents to obey the rules. “They said, ‘We don’t want the virus here,’” said a 25-year-old delivery driver from the neighborhood who out of fear asked to be identified only by his first name, Miguel.
“People are not afraid of the police, but of the gang,” he said.
The gangs are thinking ahead.
He said the gangs worry that high rates of infection could do long-term damage to their business and bring unwanted attention from government authorities. For now, the gangs appear willing to accept some losses.
In a neighborhood controlled by an offshoot of the Barrio 18 gang in San Salvador, hit men have told small-business owners and taxi drivers that they are exempt from paying extortion fees, known as renta, while the quarantine lasts.
But it is unclear how long the newfound peace will last. “Once the quarantine ends, they’ll have to pay what they owe,” said a barber in the neighborhood, who asked to be identified only by his first name, Rafael. “I think that homicides are going to increase after the quarantine because the gang is not going to forgive the debt, and they are going to kill whoever does not pay.”
Could the lockdowns result in societal unrest?
Here and across Latin America, which last year saw a wave of protest movements in several countries over income inequality, there are growing concerns about possible social unrest if lockdowns continue. “El Salvador’s fragile economy could collapse,” said Jeannete Aguilar, a security analyst in San Salvador. Half of the nation’s population works in the informal economy, she said, and few have savings.
And what about remittances, accounting for about 20% of El Salvador's GDP?
Remittances from abroad — which account for roughly 20% of the country’s GDP — are already falling, she said.
“A quarantine is a different thing if your refrigerator is empty,” she said. “There could be a huge increase in robberies and other crime because people are desperate and hungry.”
She is among a growing number of experts who believe a global recession — and the likelihood of attendant violence —
might fuel new waves of migration to the United States.
Any social phenomenon can "fuel new waves of migration to the United States." But not if we stop it.
What about Guatemala and Honduras?
In Guatemala and Honduras, homicides have dropped by about a third, in large part because there are fewer people on the streets to threaten and kill.
On the other hand, gangs, like any successful business enterprise, have to roll with the flow to stay profitable. That's what Tiziano Breda said about Guatemala.
[Breda] said that gangs in Guatemala were already evolving in the face of coronavirus-related restrictions, including the suspension of bus routes, that have deprived them of income. Some gangs have shifted to extorting people in their homes instead of their places of business, he said.
[Breda] worries that gangs may also have their sights on the $130-per-family subsidies promised by the government to counter the economic devastation that the coronavirus is expected to bring to one of the world’s poorest countries.
But what about Mexico?
One nation in the region that has not seen a decrease in crime is Mexico, which recorded 2,585 homicides in March, according to preliminary government data. That is more than in any month in nearly two years.
April is off to a similarly bloody start. Over the weekend, a shootout between rival drug cartels left 19 people dead in the northern border state of Chihuahua....
In some parts of Mexico, armed groups have been preparing for a possible lockdown. Gangs in Tamaulipas and Michoacan states were reported to be dispensing food and other supplies to local residents this week.
In Guerrero state, which is controlled by a patchwork of armed gangs and self-proclaimed self-defense groups, some have set up checkpoints around their communities to keep the virus out, said Falko Ernst, senior analyst for Mexico at the International Crisis Group.
He says he worries that in parts of the country where law and order is largely absent, the coronavirus may only embolden armed groups, especially as Mexican soldiers and other federal forces are moved from peacekeeping activities to coronavirus containment efforts.
“We are at risk of these conflicts being further unleashed,” Ernst said.
Let's get that wall built and continue the current policy of sending illegals right back across the border.