"Innocent" Illegal Immigrants Are Being Deported From New York
Print Friendly and PDF

Albor Ruiz, Email him a Hispanic writer for the New York Daily News, has a column that suggests that "innocent" immigrants are being deported—but it turns out that they're not innocent:

No sanctuary from Immigration and Customs Enforcement grip for innocent

By Albor Ruiz - NY Daily News, November 14th 2010

It is called Secure Communities, but its critics say the name doesn't reflect the reality of what the federal program actually does.

Growing concern over New York State's involvement with this controversial program, as well as the collaboration between the city Department of Correction and Immigration and Customs Enforcement, spurred a City Council hearing last Wednesday.

With the city's acquiescence, ICE has maintained a presence in Rikers Island for over a decade and routinely checks the fingerprints against immigration records of everyone arrested. As a result, critics believe, hundreds of innocent people are deported.

Now that would be worrying if he meant that people who were American citizens or legal immigrants being deported. A mentally retarded man named Pedro Guzman (who was born in America) was deported from a Los Angeles jail because he wouldn't admit to being mentally retarded and say "Call my parents."[Disabled man found after 89-day ordeal By Sam Quinones, Los Angeles Times, August 8, 2007]

This is not the fault of the ICE or the immigration system—it's not their fault that a retarded man is wandering around unsupervised by his family or anyone else.

Of course the ACLU made much of this case because they can use it as a stick to bash the whole deportation system. But Ruiz, who is savage in his hatred of the Minutemen and Samuel Huntington, but for some reason pro-Castro, isn't talking about people like that.

He's talking about innocent illegal immigrants who are "innocent" in the sense that the New York judicial system has been unable to convict them of felony, but obviously guilty of being deportable illegals.

One of those testifying was Udi Ofer, the New York Civil Liberties Union advocacy director. He reminded Council members that local immigration enforcement efforts weaken public safety and threaten everyone's constitutional rights.

"Currently in New York City, federal immigration authorities have a permanent presence in our city's jails, and may soon have a direct line to our local police precincts," Ofer said. "As a result, what may have once been a sanctuary city has now become a municipality that facilitates the deportation of thousands of its residents every year."

Actually, the NYCLU found that between 2004 and 2009, more than 13,000 Rikers Island inmates were placed into deportation proceedings. Many were not criminals or violent felons, but asylum seekers, victims of human trafficking, permanent residents, juveniles, women seeking protection from domestic violence and individuals without a criminal record.

ICE records obtained through a Freedom of Information Act request show that innocent people are most affected by Secure Communities.

ICE's own records reveal that nearly 79% of individuals deported nationally through the Secure Communities program from October 2008 through June 2010 had no criminal record or were arrested for minor offenses.

However, the mayor's office claims the situation in the city is different.

We "found that 72% of those with detainers had prior convictions - and 60% of those with convictions had at least one felony conviction. Obviously, those are very big numbers. Not honoring ICE's detainers would create serious public safety and national security risks,"said Stu Loeser , a Bloomberg spokesman, signaling City Hall's willingness to participate in Secure Communities.

"But we are going to be carefully watching the implementation of the program to make sure it is done right," he promised.

Yet, as Council Speaker Christine Quinn said at the hearing, everyone understands the goal of collaborating with ICE is to keep New Yorkers "safe from individuals who are criminals and could do harm."

But, Quinn added, "Many appropriate concerns have been raised that the way the DOC is working with ICE has granted them such latitude that the implementation of this program goes far beyond."

And thousands of innocent people pay the consequences.

No they don't—they're illegal immigrants. They didn't innocently ford the Rio Grande, innocently lie on visa applications, innocently lie to the immigration authorities, or innocently apply for work for which they had no work permit. They're guilty. And so is Ruiz, for lying about it.

Print Friendly and PDF