Dr. Norm Matloff In Barrons On The Misconception That Foreign Engineers Are The "Best And Brightest" (In Fact, They're The Cheapest)
Print Friendly and PDF

Dr. Norm Matloff writes to his email list:

Barron's kindly ran my op-ed over the weekend.  I wasn't going to mention it here, as it makes arguments that I've made repeatedly in this e-newsletter.  However, a number of people have asked to see it, as Barron's does not display the full text online.

Thus I have posted the full text here: Where Are the "Best and Brightest?", June 8, 2013

A thoughtful commentary on my article is here: Immigration and the ‘Best and Brightest’, American Spectator, By G. Tracy Mehan, III, June 10, 2013

One small point in response to that commentary:  The author says my restriction to natives "grates" on him.  I fully agree; it grates on me too, and I try to avoid it whenever possible.  As many of you probably know, I usually take the word "American" to mean U.S. citizens and permanent residents, where the citizens category includes naturalized citizens.  However, in my analysis in this case, I did indeed restrict to natives, for reasons which I describe in detail in my EPI paper: Are foreign students the ‘best and brightest’? Data and implications for immigration policy, February 28, 2013


Archived at http://heather.cs.ucdavis.edu/Archive/Barrons.txt

Print Friendly and PDF