Ellison Lodge’s blog post discusses how the gossip site Gawker wanted Yale Alumni Magazine to censor Jared Taylor. [Stop the Presses, Yale Alumni Magazine Publishes Letter by Yale Alumnus, July 31, 2011]
After reading their attack on Taylor, I took a look at the comments. Surprisingly, almost none of them had to do with Taylor. The first comment unintentionally complimented Taylor by saying he is “just following in the footsteps of another venerable Yale alum, John C. Calhoun,” and the rest of the comments simply trashed Calhoun.
Various photos of Calhoun and his famous stern expression were posted with comments like “he was the worst, his ugliness comes from the inside out, how did anyone take him seriously and not run away screaming in terror?” [All Your White Supremacist Yale Classmates Say Hi, July 29, 2011, John Cook (comment section)]
I normally, don’t post on comments, but as this was such a silly line of attack, I felt compelled to defend his looks and wrote,
“John C. Calhoun died in 1850, so he was only photographed in the last years of his life. In the early days of photography, a daguerreotype had to be exposed for upwards of 30 minutes and the subject had to stay still the entire time. In his advanced years, Calhoun had an oddly stern expression when he could not move his mouth for such a long period of time.
However, by all accounts he was a handsome man, as evidenced by this portrait. Yes, this is silly to bring up, but if you are going to make a political point by calling someone who died 160 years ago ugly, you should at least get our facts straight.”
I attached this portrait of a younger Calhoun. I don’t think anything I wrote could remotely be categorized as offensive or “racist,” though I expected for a few of the progressives to call me gay. Nonetheless, I found my post deleted a couple hours later.
Apparently explaining why someone had an odd facial expression in 1840s photographs is not permitted if the person in question owned slaves.