From: Joe-Pop Bachofen [Email him]
In the interest of clarity can you add one educational feature to your website? Please provide a clear list of the "philosophies, values, social structure, attitudes, festivals, foods and aesthetic" that define America along with the Article in the Constitution of the United States or the Amendment thereof that defines those. Also, in the interest of intelligent dialogue, consider the following questions:
To be frank, I would not invite you into my home to hold a meeting with people that share your beliefs because I see the obvious flaws in your premise.
Nonetheless, the 5 "flaws" I listed above could be considered to be my beliefs which I think are easily defensible and I would welcome a discussion with you about those topics simply because the most valuable question I have found to protect myself from self delusion is: What if I'm wrong?
Please consider asking yourself the same question.
In my experience, the most valuable discussions are those I had with people that disagree with me; not because either of us convinced the other but because respectful discussion is the key to understanding.
I do hope you understand what I have written.
James Fulford writes: I do understand what the reader has written. It’s called high level virtue-signalling. However, to answer two of his questions, we don’t need to provide a specific list of the "philosophies, values, social structure, attitudes, festivals, foods and aesthetic" because, to quote Louis Armstrong, "If you have to ask, you'll never know."
As for “the Article in the Constitution of the United States or the Amendment thereof” that would define such things, that is case of “not getting it” about the National Question. The American Nation wasn’t created by Constitution—it existed before the both Constitution and the Declaration—and continues to do so.