More States Require Voter ID
Print Friendly and PDF

For the elections-have-consequences file: since January, six states have enacted laws requiring photo ID to vote, largely because of Republican legislatures. That’s a blow for honesty in elections, as far as I’m concerned, and will hopefully help keep illegal aliens out of the voting booths.

The liberal argument that minorities and poor people don’t have identification is bogus and a distraction. Libs think that sovereignty and citizenship are too old-fashioned, and illegal aliens should be allowed to vote, as San Franciscans have voted on twice in the last few years.

More states require ID to vote, USA Today, June 19, 2011

State legislatures across the country have passed a record number of laws this year requiring photo identification to vote, a controversial move pushed by Republicans and opposed by Democrats.

Proponents say the measures prevent vote fraud. Opponents say they are designed to stifle turnout among students, poor people and minorities, who are more likely to vote for Democrats but might lack government-issued IDs, such as driver’s licenses and passports.

Buoyed by big Republican gains in the 2010 elections, six states have enacted photo ID laws since January — Alabama, Kansas, South Carolina, Texas, Tennessee and Wisconsin. Bills in New Hampshire and North Carolina await gubernatorial action.

The measures, all passed by Republican-controlled legislatures, could bring to 17 the number of states with photo ID requirements and come nearly 18 months before elections for Congress and the White House. Other states — including Florida, Georgia, Tennessee and West Virginia— have reduced the period for early voting.

In Florida, a key battleground state, a law signed last month by Republican Gov. Rick Scott also restricts efforts to register new voters by groups such as the League of Women Voters.

“It’s remarkable,” Jennie Bowser, a senior fellow at the National Conference of State Legislatures, said of the proliferation of new laws. In all, 33 states have considered new voter ID laws this year. “I very rarely see one single issue come up in so many state legislatures in a single session,” she said. “This issue has historically fallen along stark partisan lines. Democrats tend to oppose voter ID, and Republicans tend to favor it. This year, there are a lot of new Republican majorities in legislatures.”

Republicans now control both legislative chambers in 26 states, up from 14 in 2010.

David Axelrod, a top strategist in President Obama’s re-election campaign, called the wave of new legislation a “calculated strategy” by Republicans to “hold down voter turnout.”

“I find it ironic at a time when all over the world people are struggling, marching, even dying, for the right to vote and cast meaningful votes that anybody in this country would be working to limit the franchise,” Axelrod told USA TODAY.

He said the campaign would “organize vigorously” to make voters aware of the new requirements.

“This is the most significant assault on voting rights that we have seen in a long time,” said Wendy Weiser of New York University’s Brennan Center for Justice, which opposes the new rules.

Proponents say the changes have little to do with politics.

State Rep. Patricia Harless, a Houston Republican who sponsored the voter ID measure in the Texas House of Representatives, said the new law is “just a way to help protect the integrity of in-person voting.”

The Texas law bars the use of student identification cards for voting, but allows the use of concealed weapons permits. for that purpose. Harless said information provided on student IDs across the state is inconsistent and few Texans lack driver’s licenses and other approved forms of identification.

“Texas, you know, is a big handgun state,” she said, “so everybody has almost got a concealed handgun license over 21.” Like other states requiring photo IDs, Texas also will provide state-issued IDs to voters who seek them, free of charge.

Experts on election law say there is scant evidence of voter fraud problems in U.S. elections, but they say it’s also too soon to tell whether new voter ID requirements will hurt turnout.

“I am skeptical of all claims made in this arena,” said Charles Stewart, an MIT political scientist and voting expert.

“Supporters of the voter ID laws have little evidence that there are problems with voting that would be solved by these laws,” he said. “On the other hand … people who really care about laws about access to the polls oftentimes overestimate the effect of these reforms on turnout.”

Print Friendly and PDF