They deserve 5 stars for not hiding the fact that they are a legitimate anti-immigration group, but zero stars for associating themselves with white nationalists, bigots, anti-Semites, etc... They use the classic tactic of pretending to be victimized by immigration to appeal to young disillusioned whites. They hide behind free speech but rarely condone [sic, he means rarely condemn] racism and hate. They have hosted, applauded, and affiliated with so many hateful white supremacist-types that they will never escape their hate group designation. Definitely a group the FBI, The Department of Justice, Police departments everywhere, The Southern Law Poverty Center, and AntiFa need to closely monitor, infiltrate, and keep an eye on.
Their Wikipedia page best describes the group:
The group has been described as white supremacist. The Southern Poverty Law Center describes VDARE as "an anti-immigration hate website" which "regularly publishes articles by prominent white nationalists, race scientists and anti-Semites", including Steve Sailer, Jared Taylor, J. Philippe Rushton and Samuel T. Francis.James Fulford writes: This gentleman seems to feel that having thoughts he considers hateful is some kind of crime to be investigated by the FBI, etc. It's not, and such an investigation would have major First Amendment implications.
As for his suggestion that Antifa should be involved in this monitoring, et cetera, that's even more inappropriate—Antifa is a criminal organization. They and the FBI can investigate each other.