Tech Titans (And Wives): Have You No Shame About Bypassing US Citizens?
Print Friendly and PDF

I guess that, when you get rich enough, you float in your own little world of noblesse oblige and feel, almost like a drug high, that you and your similarly-minded pals are above the law, above the mere bonds of common sense, probity and, egad, that you are not a citizen of a sovereign nation where 25 million of your fellow citizens are out of work, underemployed or have stopped looking for work.

This strikes me as descriptive of the folks identified in Miriam Jordan’s Page One March 7, 2012 WSJ story “Tech Titans Fund Students”:

 A group of Silicon Valley technology leaders, impatient with attempts to rewrite immigration laws, is funding efforts to help undocumented youths attend college, find jobs and stay in the country despite their illegal status.

The group includes Jeff Hawkins, inventor of the Palm Pilot; and the family foundations of Andrew Grove, co-founder of Intel Corp.; and Mark Leslie, founder of the former Veritas Software Corp. Laurene Powell Jobs, widow of Apple Inc. co-founder Steve Jobs, has for years supported undocumented students through her organizations that help low-income high-school students.”

To adapt the famous Joseph Welch question to Senator Joe McCarthy at the Army–McCarthy hearings:   “Have you no sense of decency, sir? At long last, have you left no sense of decency?"

Jordan (no, not, sadly Barbara) continues:

 “The Silicon Valley money is part of a broader response by individuals and states to Congress, which hasn't passed the Dream Act. That federal legislation would offer a path to legalization for illegal immigrants who graduate from a U.S. high school and attend college or join the military.”

Of course, this “news” article prioritizes opinions:

 "We think Congress's inaction…is devastating for these students and tragic for the country," said Ms. Powell Jobs, who was one of the first in the tech community to champion the Dream Act by lobbying her congresswoman and writing an op-ed piece supporting the legislation.

The focus of the Silicon Valley philanthropists is Educators for Fair Consideration, or E4FC, a nonprofit that gives scholarships, career advice and legal services to students brought to the U.S. illegally as children.

The WSJ’s Jordan does note:

“Companies that knowingly hire illegal immigrants can face civil and criminal penalties. Among other ideas, the Silicon Valley donors are studying the possibility of using unpaid internships as way for students to come to the attention of employers who might later sponsor them for a legal work visa.” 

But then, who’s counting or enforcing?

And this is by no means a small uncoordinated operation:

After helping a few dozen students through college with small donations, the San Francisco-based organization expanded with money from the tech leaders. It now has enlisted immigration attorneys to offer legal advice to hundreds of undocumented students.

"We used to think, 'Let's just get them through college'" with scholarships, said Katharine Gin, a teacher who founded E4FC along with a college counselor. "We thought the federal Dream Act would pass and we would be helping these students in the interim period only."

Several of the Silicon Valley supporters became aware of the issue close up: Mr. Hawkins got to know an undocumented student at his daughters' high school. Liz Simons, daughter of the founder of hedge fund Renaissance Technologies, mentored an undocumented honor student in high school who was struggling to raise funds for college because of his illegal status. Seth Leslie, son of Veritas's founder, had encountered undocumented students in his work as a schoolteacher and principal.”

Let us review this situation.  You let a bad situation languish for decades creating a layer of illegal barnacles attach to the hull of the good ship Uncle Sam, and you find those with money and influence confused and sympathetic to the woes of those they see and want to help.

But what about the estimated 1 million-plus US citizen engineers now under or unemployed? They have families too.

I liken the thoughtless wish to help these kids, many of whom are no doubt attractive, to the appeal of a litter of new puppies—aren’t they so cute? But our older out-of-work folks are like stray mongrels, fit only for the dog pound.

Jordan tells us that

“The money involved is relatively small: The tech philanthropists and others gave hundreds of thousands dollars in the last year to the group, whose 2012 operating budget is $600,000.”  

Recall Mrs. Romney only has two Cadillacs.

Jordan tells us,

"I have chosen to make this one of my philanthropic areas," said Mr. Hawkins, who disclosed his giving for the first time in an interview but declined to state the amount. "It's still at an embryonic stage; I'm willing to crank it up as we find solutions."

Jordan finally reports the opinion of the majority of our citizens.

To opponents, the bill is tantamount to an amnesty program for children whose parents broke U.S. immigration laws; they argue it would entice more people to sneak into the country. President Barack Obama supports the Dream Act; Republican Mitt Romney has said he would veto the measure if elected president.

On hearing of the efforts by the group, Ira Mehlman, a spokesman for the Federation for American Immigration Reform, a national group that lobbies against legalization, said: "You'd think they would help people in the country legally who face difficult times getting a start."

So you see the barnacles pile up as

 The Supreme Court has ruled it unconstitutional to deny a K-12 public education to children who are in the country illegally.

But after that, their future is uncertain because they can't qualify for federal grants, work-study programs or bank loans to finance college nor can they obtain work legally.

U.S. tech companies have long backed raising the number of visas the government issues for skilled immigrants such as software engineers, and argue the country is losing its competitive edge as other economies attract skilled labor forces.

At a recent gathering in Los Altos, Calif., an undocumented 23-year-old with a degree in civil engineering, which he obtained on a scholarship, told funders of E4FC that he had five job offers in the last two months, only to have them revoked because of his immigration status. He said he has been willing to work for no pay to accrue experience required for a professional engineering license. Even that has proved challenging.”

I am sure that the folks, who can afford their moral grandstanding, will be soon be pushing another amnesty.

“The U.S. has "put a lot of money into [undocumented students] already," said Eva Grove, wife of Intel's co-founder, whose family foundation gave $1 million to immigration-related groups last year."It makes no sense to dead-end them after they are educated."

So screw the poor, out-of-work US citizens, let them eat pizza—while the elite push more unneeded mouths in front of those who are legally here.

Collins, [email him], a free lance writer living in Washington, DC. , is CoChair of the National Advisory Board of the Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR). However, his views are his own.

Print Friendly and PDF